Dolphin Sigma vs Premier: Robotic Pool Cleaner Comparison

Dolphin Sigma vs Premier which should you buy

A pool is all fun and cool until you have to clean it. Cleaning a pool is not nearly as exciting as relaxing in it, yet it’s something that has to be done. This is why a robotic pool cleaner is an essential gadget for any home with a pool, and Dolphin still tops the list of premium pool cleaners.

Two exotic Dolphin pool cleaners; Sigma and Premier are currently on the list of top pool robots for large in-ground pools. And this piece is apparently a Dolphin Sigma vs Premier showdown. So, grab a cup of your favorite beverage and lets go for a ride!

Sigma and Premier are two evenly matched robots, they aren’t just designed to get the job done, but are also packed full with exciting features for optimal performance and convenience. 

*The links in this page are affiliate links, this means that if you purchase after following one, I make a small commission from the sale at no additional cost to yourself. Take a look at our About Us page for more info on this.

Dolphin Sigma vs Premier: which should you buy?

Dolphin Sigma
Dolphin Sigma Robotic Pool Cleaner with Bluetooth and Massive Top-Load Cartridge Filters, Ideal for...
Dolphin Premier
Dolphin Premier Robotic Pool Cleaner with Powerful Dual Scrubbing Brushes and Multiple Filter...
Pool Size
Up to 50 feet
Up to 50 feet
Pool Type
Gunite/Plaster, Vinyl, Fiberglass
Gunite/Plaster, Vinyl, Fiberglass
Pool Cleaning
Scrubs, Floor, Walls & Tile/Waterline
Scrubs, Floor, Walls & Tile/Waterline
Filtration System
Fine & Ultra Fine
Multi-Media, Oversized Leaf Bag, Fine, Ultra-Fine Cartridge
Anti-tangle Cord
App Control
Warranty
3-Years
3-Years
-
$1,298.00
$1,147.00
Dolphin Sigma
Dolphin Sigma Robotic Pool Cleaner with Bluetooth and Massive Top-Load Cartridge Filters, Ideal for...
Pool Size
Up to 50 feet
Pool Type
Gunite/Plaster, Vinyl, Fiberglass
Pool Cleaning
Scrubs, Floor, Walls & Tile/Waterline
Filtration System
Fine & Ultra Fine
Anti-tangle Cord
App Control
Warranty
3-Years
-
$1,298.00
Dolphin Premier
Dolphin Premier Robotic Pool Cleaner with Powerful Dual Scrubbing Brushes and Multiple Filter...
Pool Size
Up to 50 feet
Pool Type
Gunite/Plaster, Vinyl, Fiberglass
Pool Cleaning
Scrubs, Floor, Walls & Tile/Waterline
Filtration System
Multi-Media, Oversized Leaf Bag, Fine, Ultra-Fine Cartridge
Anti-tangle Cord
App Control
Warranty
3-Years
$1,147.00

Last update on 2020-05-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Between the Dolphin Sigma and Dolphin Premier, there is no doubt that the Sigma is the more advanced robot. With more premium features, the Sigma is obviously an upgraded version of the Premier. However, I’ll choose the Premier over the Sigma for my in-ground pool and this has nothing to do with price. 

Despite being the latest model with upgraded features, when it comes to the actual job of pool cleaning and maintenance, the Sigma doesn’t exactly out-perform the Premier. In fact, it’s the other way round, the Premier does a better pool cleaning job because of a number of reasons. First, the Sigma is more prone to getting stuck on pool drains than the Premier and you may have to rescue it each time by gently tugging at the cord. 

And in spite of the advanced navigation software, the Sigma misses more dirt spots than the Premier. Of course, you can direct its movement from the smartphone app but this requires some patience. Finally, the Premier has multiple filter options (both filter cartridges and debris bags) for more customized cleaning while the Sigma comes with only a filter cartridge.

Product Overviews

Dolphin Sigma

To enjoy more relaxing times at the pool and less time — actually no time — scrubbing it, you need a robotic pool cleaner to handle the messy and unpleasant chore of scrubbing and cleaning your pool. A simple gadget like the Dolphin Sigma will make any large and messy in-ground pool shiny and attractive in less than 3 hours. It’s sleek and stylishly designed with premium features, yet simple enough to understand and control, and you can give it instructions from your smartphone. The intuitive and user-friendly app lets you ‘spot clean’ and control the robot’s movement in the pool. 

Sale
Dolphin Sigma Robotic Pool Cleaner with Bluetooth and Massive Top-Load Cartridge Filters, Ideal for...
  • Hassle-free clean. Easy-to-use, robotic pool cleaner equipped with an anti-tangling swivel cable, allowing Sigma to move freely around large residential pools up to 50 feet with ease. Backed by a 3...

Last update on 2020-05-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Dolphin Premier

Dolphin Premier is a pool robot that promises to automate pool cleaning and it does deliver on that. If you have a large in-ground pool and need a premium robotic pool cleaner to scrub and suck away all forms of dirt and pool contaminants, you’ve got one here. With exciting features that are both efficient and convenient, this robot works to give you the exotic lifestyle you’ve always wanted — no messy chores and more time on your hands for what really matters to you. This robotic pool cleaner requires no set-up, no fittings or installations, it’s simply plug in and play.  

Dolphin Premier Robotic Pool Cleaner with Powerful Dual Scrubbing Brushes and Multiple Filter...
  • Drop and go. Easy to use, single button plug and play in-ground robotic pool cleaner ideal for pools up to 50 feet; backed by a 3 year quality assurance.

Last update on 2020-05-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

How they work

The Sigma and Premier are sister products from Maytronics. These are two premium pool cleaners specially designed for large in-ground pools of over 50 ft. Both the Sigma and the Premier come equipped with HyperGrip rubber tracks, with which they steadily move in the pool. 

Both robots also have dual high-speed scrubbing brushes for attacking and loosing all forms of dirt. A powerful suction forces the loosened dirt particles and pool contaminants in a standard filter cartridge where they are trapped. 

To ensure efficient and thorough cleaning, these robots feature the SmartNav technology. With this, they are able to scan the pool and map out the quickest cleaning route. 

The Sigma has an upgraded version of this software and also has gyroscope sensors for advanced navigation. Dolphin Sigma also has Bluetooth which connects to the MyDolphin app, with this you can control your Sigma remotely from your smartphone, this feature is absent in the Premier. 

Both robots come with 60 ft anti-tangle swivel cable and LED lights for indicating when the filter cartridges/debris bags are full. These gadgets complete a cleaning cycle in just under 3 hours and can easily maintain any large in-ground pool. 

Key features 

24-volts DC motors

Premier comes with two 24-volt DC motors while the Sigma has three 24-volt DC motors. Despite this difference, these two robots are energy efficient and run at the same 180 wattage which is an average of  $0.05/hr.

Multi-media filtration

Sigma has a large top-loader cartridge filter for trapping fine and ultra-fine dirt particles while the Premier has bottom-loader cartridge filters for ultra-fine/fine dirt particles and over-sized debris bags for leaves, twigs, sticks, and others large floating pool contaminants. 

Dolphin Premier Robotic Pool Cleaner with Powerful Dual Scrubbing Brushes and Multiple Filter...

Anti-tangle swivel cable

Both robots have the patented 60-foot anti-tangle swivel cord made from thermoplastic rubber to prevent frictional drag. This cable also rotates through 360-degrees and promotes glitch-free movement. 

SmartNav technology

Both Sigma and Premier feature the SmartNav system for advanced pool navigation. With this software, these robots are able to scan the pool and create a map for quick and efficient cleaning. This prevents uncoordinated movements, and saves time and energy.

HyperGrip rubber tracks

Instead of wheels, these Dolphin pool robots both use specially designed HyperGrip continuous rubber tracks. These tracks counter any loss of friction due to water and firmly plant these robots on the floors and walls of pools. This ensures that the robot moves smoothly while getting the job done.

High-speed brushes

With four high-speed spinning brushes, these robots attack and scrub off all dirt and grime. These brushes are strategically positioned (two at the front and two behind) to get to every corner of the pool. 

Dolphin Sigma Robotic Pool Cleaner with Bluetooth and Massive Top-Load Cartridge Filters, Ideal for...

Dolphin Sigma vs Premier — the key differences 

These Dolphin pool robots are basically the same with many similar features. They’re both designed to thoroughly clean large in-ground pools and both come with the 60-ft anti-tangle swivel cable and the SmartNav technology. 

Both robots also have similar weekly timer and 4500 GPH suction rate, and these premium robots both cost over $1000, but there are differences. First, the Dolphin Premier has dual 24V DC motors while Dolphin Sigma has three 24V DC motors which deliver more power for faster cleaning. 

The Premier also has the much older bottom-filter loading design while the Sigma has a large top-loader micron cartridge filter, which is a more convenient design. Sigma has gyroscope sensors for better maneuverability and navigation, this ensures the robot can tilt and turn for more efficient and thorough cleaning, this feature is absent in the Premier. 

Sigma also comes with Bluetooth connectivity and a smartphone app for remote control while the Premier only has an optional remote control (which isn’t available for Sigma) and no smartphone app. Dolphin Premier also has a caddy which you can purchase as an extra but there isn’t one for the Sigma. Dolphin Sigma obviously has more premium features than the Premier and that accounts for the difference in price. 

Maytronics Dolphi sigma review shows the robotic pool cleaner is excellent at cleaning the waterline

How do they perform? 

When comparing the Dolphin Premier vs the Sigma, both robots are designed to automatically clean large in-ground pool and they do it beautifully. They are able to clean the pool floor and walls, and up to the waterline. Despite being premium gadgets, these robots are not without flaws. 

First, occasionally you may find each one stuck on your pool’s raised drain, when this happens, the robot with try to work it’s way out but sometimes you may have to give it the cable a little tug to help free the robot. The Premier has an optional remote control which isn’t very useful, while he Sigma has a mobile app for remote control. 

Manually controlling these robots can be very slow and tiring, and you’ll have to be patient with it. Between these two, the Sigma has an advanced navigation software and one extra motor, this makes it faster than the Premier, but not exactly better. Sigma gets the job done within a shorter time but Premier does a better cleaning job overall. 

Ease of set-up and use

Despite the advanced features and somewhat complex engineering by Maytronics, these pool robots are actually very simple machines and they require no set-up or installation. Each robot comes as a complete package with everything you’ll need to get it to do the work, they both work right out of the box. 

Simply unwind the swivel cable, connect the power supply, drop the robot in your pool and turn it on. They both have similar controls, the difference being that Sigma has Bluetooth and a smartphone app while Premier doesn’t. You can set each robot to clean weekly using the weekly timer. Sigma has a top-loader cartridge filter which is easier to remove and empty, while Premier features a bottom-loader. 

Dolphin Premier Robotic Pool Cleaner with Powerful Dual Scrubbing Brushes and Multiple Filter...

Reliability 

The biggest challenge with these robots is that they tend to get stuck on pool drains and the Sigma is more prone to this than the Premier. This little quirk means you can’t trust the robot to do great job when you’re not home to watch it. 

They also aren’t excellent at cleaning pool steps and you may have to manually scrub those steps yourself, especially the shallow parts. The Sigma will likely miss some dirt spots while cleaning, so you’ll have to use the ‘spot clean’ feature in the app to get the missed spots. For the Premier, you have to get the remote control to be able to change the robot’s direction in the pool. 

These machines are sturdily built and each have a 3-year warranty from Maytronics. However, there have been reports of breakdown shortly after purchase and unfortunately Maytronics doesn’t respond fast enough to queries and complaints.

Ongoing maintenance

These Dolphin pool cleaners are simple gadgets and they require very little maintenance. The major thing you’ll have to do as frequently as possible (after a few cleaning cycles) is to always empty the filter cartridges and rinse out the filter screen with a running water from a garden hose. 

The Sigma has a large top-loader filter while the Premier has bottom-loader cartridges and optional debris bags. You’ll also have to check wear and replace worn parts as soon as possible to make sure the performance of the robot isn’t compromised. Both the Sigma and Premier are backed by a 3-year quality assurance from Maytronics. 

The Maytronics Sigma cleans all pool types

Extra purchases and ongoing costs 

All Dolphin pool cleaners come with all the essential parts and will need no extra purchases to get started with it, although you can purchase some extras for convenience. For instance, the Premier has a caddy and a remote control and both come at an extra costs, the Sigma has neither of these. These gadgets come both come with a 3-year warranty, you should also expect to purchase replacement parts when need be, especially for wearable parts like brushes and filter cartridges.  

Final Thoughts comparing the Dolphin Sigma vs Premier

Apparently, Dolphin Sigma has more premium features and is an upgraded version of the Dolphin Premier. However, both pool robots provide approximately the same cleaning power, they both thoroughly clean floors, walls and every corner of a pool. 

The Sigma also costs significantly higher than the Premier, which is to be expected. Despite the advanced engineering from Maytronics, these gadgets do have their quirks. But once you’re able to go around these minor drawback, you’ll have a swell time with your Dolphin pool cleaner — whichever one you decide to go for. 

You May Also Like

About the Author: matt